Smile.io vs Yotpo Loyalty

Updated · How we collect this data

Smile.io runs on 8,335 live Shopify stores and Yotpo Loyalty on 5,039. Here is how the two loyalty & rewards tools compare on real adoption: by country, overlap, and the stores using each.

Smile.io vs Yotpo Loyalty: active Shopify stores Smile.io 8,335 Yotpo Loyalty 5,039
Smile.io is installed on 1.7x as many Shopify stores as Yotpo Loyalty; 89 stores use both.

Which is more popular on Shopify, Smile.io or Yotpo Loyalty?

Smile.io is more widely used on Shopify than Yotpo Loyalty: we detect Smile.io on 8,335 active stores (0.8% of all stores we track) and Yotpo Loyalty on 5,039 (0.5%) as of November 2026, a ratio of about 1.7 to 1. 89 stores run both at the same time (1.8% of Yotpo Loyalty stores), which usually means a migration in progress or each tool covering a different job. Yotpo Loyalty leads in Netherlands, while Smile.io leads everywhere else among the largest Shopify countries. Both have their biggest market in United States, with 3,849 stores on Smile.io and 2,780 on Yotpo Loyalty. Well-known stores on Smile.io without Yotpo Loyalty include ニューエラオンラインストア and Durex India, while New Era Cap and Tuckernuck chose Yotpo Loyalty. Adoption shows what stores actually choose; it does not measure price, features or support quality, so use it alongside a feature comparison.

At a glance

Smile.ioYotpo Loyalty
Active Shopify stores8,3355,039
Share of all stores0.8%0.5%
Largest marketUnited States (3,849)United States (2,780)
Most often used withMeta Pixel (76.6%)Yotpo (100%)
Stores using both89

Smile.io vs Yotpo Loyalty by country

Share of each country's active Shopify stores using each tool, for the largest markets of either.

CountrySmile.ioYotpo LoyaltyLeader
United States 1.1% (3,849) 0.8% (2,780) Smile.io
United Kingdom 0.9% (824) 0.5% (431) Smile.io
Canada 1.4% (705) 0.5% (265) Smile.io
Australia 0.9% (516) 0.7% (403) Smile.io
Singapore 3.5% (259) 0.9% (64) Smile.io
France 0.4% (170) 0.3% (119) Smile.io
India 0.4% (232) 0.1% (42) Smile.io
Hong Kong SAR China 1% (207) 0.3% (55) Smile.io
New Zealand 1.5% (182) 0.5% (63) Smile.io
Germany 0.2% (95) 0.2% (91) Smile.io
Netherlands 0.2% (61) 0.4% (105) Yotpo Loyalty
Mexico 0.8% (121) 0.3% (44) Smile.io

Top Shopify stores using both Smile.io and Yotpo Loyalty

# Store Country Theme Products Popularity
1 eyebobs United States · Minneapolis Custom 362 Top 500k
2 Sweetie Nail Supply Canada · Markham Impact 5,060 Top 500k
3 LotusAndLuna United States · San Diego Ultimate 403 Top 500k
4 the Vitamin Shoppe Paraguay Paraguay · Asuncion Providence 591 Top 500k
5 KatieJNYC United States · Roslyn Impulse 1,683 Top 1M
6 Peinture Algo France · Vern-sur-Seiche Dawn 718 Top 1M
7 ZING Toothpaste United Kingdom · London Ultimate 29 Top 1M
8 Active Booty United States · Kentland Symmetry 33 Top 5M
9 AmazingCosmetics United States · Bostic Be Yours 18 Top 5M
10 Auntie K Candy United States · Milpitas Symmetry 248 Top 5M

Top stores using Smile.io but not Yotpo Loyalty

# Store Country Theme Products Popularity
1 ニューエラオンラインストア Japan · 目黒区 Exo 14,377 Top 50k
2 Durex India India · Gurugram Dawn 106 Top 50k
3 Nine West United States · Greenwich Marc Fisher Brands 1,591 Top 100k
4 Ever-Pretty US United States · Irvine Focal 834 Top 100k
5 Sand + Fog United States · Huntington Beach Broadcast 2,182 Top 100k
6 KIKAGoods Hong Kong SAR China · Hong Kong Broadcast 943 Top 100k
7 Pound Fabrics United Kingdom · Birmingham Flex 2,249 Top 100k
8 Matkatus India · Chennai Impulse 4,470 Top 100k
9 Liquid Death United States · Los Angeles Liquid Death 216 Top 500k
10 Al Rugaib Furniture Saudi Arabia · AL KHOBAR Sleek 24,058 Top 500k

Top stores using Yotpo Loyalty but not Smile.io

# Store Country Theme Products Popularity
1 New Era Cap United States · Buffalo Dawn 25,000+ Top 50k
2 Tuckernuck United States · Washington Tuckernuck Redesign 16,749 Top 50k
3 Loop Earplugs Belgium · Antwerpen Loop 51 Top 50k
4 Disturbia United Kingdom · Cramlington Prestige 3,538 Top 50k
5 Manucurist France · PARIS Be Yours 536 Top 50k
6 Disturbia United States · Grove City Prestige 3,262 Top 50k
7 Scuffers Spain · Pozuelo de Alarcón Showcase 1,673 Top 50k
8 Ashley Stewart United States · Secaucus Ella 3,662 Top 50k
9 POPFLEX® United States · Austin Symmetry 1,123 Top 50k
10 Cold Culture Spain · Madrid Prestige 1,701 Top 50k

Smile.io usage data · Yotpo Loyalty usage data · Smile.io alternatives · Yotpo Loyalty alternatives

Counts are live Shopify stores where each tool is detected in homepage code. They measure adoption, not quality or price. Methodology.